【Classic case】Chinese Dispute between the XX branch of the property insurance company Co., Ltd. and Ma XX insurance
- Categories:Department of Infringement Affairs
- Time of issue:2023-01-12
- Views:
(Summary description)
【Classic case】Chinese Dispute between the XX branch of the property insurance company Co., Ltd. and Ma XX insurance
(Summary description)
- Categories:Department of Infringement Affairs
- Time of issue:2023-01-12
- Views:
【案情简介】
原告马某某系死者徐某某妻子。徐某某在交通事故中死亡。其妻子即马某某向法院提起诉讼,索要被抚养人生活费。
【盛恒成果】
一审判决结果,以马某某达到60周岁判决保险公司赔偿被抚养人生活费。保险公司不服一审判决,以一审法院适用法律错误为由提起上诉。二审法院经审理改判,撤销一审判决,改判不予支持被抚养人生活费。案例分析,在司法实践中,非常注重被抚养人是否丧失劳动能力,而忽略抚养人是否具有抚养能力。本案中,死者徐某某生前已年满71周岁,本身还需要子女赡养,根本不具有抚养原告马某某的能力。二审法院采纳代理人意见,判决不予支持被抚养人生活费。
Scan the QR code to read on your phone
底部简介
Established in 1999, Shengheng Law Firm has its development headquarters in Shenyang, China, business headquarters in Shanghai, China, and European headquarters in Frankfurt, Germany. Now it has 22 wholly-owned branch offices, with full business coverage across China and the world. Throughout over 20 years of development, Shengheng has become a globalized law firm with worldwide business, large scale, well-known brand, and high-level information technological base.
CONTACT
底部电话
Tel.:400-6180400
底部地址
Address: 62F, Forum 66 Office Building, No. 1 Youth Avenue, Shenhe District, Shenyang.
底部邮箱
E-mail:shengheng_hr@163.com
底部二维码
© 2021 LIAONING SHENGHENG LAW FIRM 辽ICP备13000363号 Powered by 300.cn